Top 10 Profitable Items to Look for in 2025 at Thrift Stores and Garage Sales
Reseller and treasure hunter Wick shares ten underrated items that are selling big on eBay in 2025. Whether you’re a full-time flipper or a weekend garage sale explorer, these finds prove that vintage tools, old hardware, and even rusty collectibles can turn into serious profits with a bit of knowledge and research.
1. Stanley Hand Planes
Antique Stanley hand planes are a must-watch item for any reseller. Depending on model, age, and condition, they can sell from $75 to over $2,000.
- Older models (1800s–early 1900s) bring higher prices.
- Rare models like the “No. 1” are especially valuable.
- Research patent dates and markings — even small differences can affect value.
Use online identification guides to confirm model numbers before listing. A rusty one might still net hundreds if it’s rare.
2. Vintage Bench Vises
Woodworking and metal vices from older brands like Wilton or Joseph H. Lewis are highly collectible.
- Common price range: $50–$500 rare ones can exceed $2,000.
- Surface rust doesn’t hurt resale value; collectors love patina.
- Shipping is simple despite weight — they’re compact and durable.
Even miniature vices can sell for hundreds. Always check the brand name and manufacturing year before passing one up.
3. Precision Micrometers and Calipers
Micrometers and calipers from brands like Starrett or Mitutoyo often look ordinary but can sell for impressive amounts.
- Average resale: $120–$1,200+, with complete sets fetching more.
- Look for wooden storage cases and half-moon shaped tools.
- Digital models or bore sets can exceed $1,000.
Even if you don’t know their use, these tools are easy to identify and always worth researching.
4. Vintage Flashlights
Old steel or brass flashlights from the 1920s–1980s are sought after by collectors. While not massive profits, they’re easy flips for quick gains.
- Valuable brands: Kel-Lite, Phillips Redhead, and early Maglite models.
- Typical resale: $100–$500.
- Even non-functioning models can sell for their design or rarity.
Bonus: Certain vintage batteries — especially sealed ones — can sell for around $80–$100 to collectors.
5. Laser Sights
Laser sights for firearms or tactical use can bring in several hundred dollars, depending on model and brand.
- Brands like SureFire can sell for $200–$400.
- These are often found at estate or hunting gear sales.
If you find one, check model numbers and confirm legality before listing.
6. Hand Drills and Auger Bit Sets
Crank-style hand drills and auger bits from brands like Irwin and Stanley are easy to spot and flip.
- Single tools sell for $50–$150.
- Complete boxed bit sets can exceed $1,000.
These stand out among generic tools, making them perfect for quick scouting at yard sales.
7. Anvils
Blacksmith anvils are surprisingly profitable and often overlooked due to their weight. Small and mid-sized versions sell well both locally and online.
- Common range: $400–$1,000+, with rare pieces reaching $2,800+.
- Old, heavy cast-iron pieces from barns or workshops are ideal finds.
- Sell locally if shipping costs are too high.
8. Axe Heads
Old axe heads are small, collectible, and valuable when tied to reputable makers.
- Top brands: Kelly, Collins, and Plumb.
- Resale value ranges from $20 to $500+.
Look for maker stamps — even without handles, collectible axe heads sell quickly to enthusiasts.
9. Woodworking Chisel Sets
Boxed or branded chisel sets are easy to recognize and bring steady profits.
- Prices range from $40 to $200+, depending on maker and completeness.
- Original wooden boxes or engraved names increase value.
10. Multi-Tools (Leatherman and Similar)
Leatherman multi-tools are one of the easiest and most consistent flips at garage sales.
- Resale range: $150–$300+.
- Commonly found in drawers or toolboxes for $1–$5.
Even used models sell quickly if you include clear photos and model details.
Bonus Finds
- Old Kel-Lite or Maglite flashlights.
- Rusty but intact Wilton vises.
- Hand-forged axe heads or hammer heads.
- Complete auger bit or chisel sets in original boxes.
Final Thoughts
The world of reselling is full of hidden treasures hiding in plain sight. From antique hand planes to heavy anvils, many items that look like scrap metal can actually bring in hundreds—or thousands—on eBay. The key is knowing what to look for and taking time to research makers and models before you buy.
Train your eye for craftsmanship, old branding, and quality materials. The next rusty tool you pass up at a garage sale might just be your biggest flip yet.